- Use 4.19 for riscv64 (earliest LTS release w/ riscv64 support)
- Use 4.9 for all others (second-oldest LTS release, released in
combination with glibc glibc 2.24 in Debian stretch)
We use these flags in our test-security-check make target, but they are
only available because debian patches them in.
We can patch them in for our Guix builds so that we can check the sanity
of our security/symbol checking suite before running them.
Support for riscv64 in glibc landed in 2.27 so it's unavoidable that we
use 2.27.
Running a Bitcoin build with toolchains based on 2.24 for platforms
other than riscv64 seem to produce binaries which do not have 2.17
symbols. So use 2.24 since it's more recent and maintained by Debian
Stretch.
aa80b5759d scripts: check macOS SDK version is set (fanquake)
c972345bac scripts: check minimum required Windows version is set (fanquake)
29615aef52 scripts: check minimum required macOS vesion is set (fanquake)
8732f7b6c9 scripts: LIEF 0.11.5 (fanquake)
Pull request description:
macOS:
We use a compile flag ([-mmacosx-version-min=10.14](https://github.com/bitcoin/bitcoin/blob/master/depends/hosts/darwin.mk#L96)) to set the minimum required version of macOS needed to run our binaries. This adds a sanity check that the version is being set as expected.
Clangs Darwin driver should infer the SDK version used during compilation, and forward that through to the linker. Add a check that this has been done, and the expected SDK version is set. Should help prevent issues like #21771 in future.
Windows:
We use linker flags ([-Wl,--major/minor-subsystem-version](https://github.com/bitcoin/bitcoin/blob/master/configure.ac#L683)) to set the minimum required version of Windows needed to run our binaries. This adds a sanity check that the version is being set as expected.
Gitian builds:
```bash
# macOS:
8b6fcd61d75001c37b2af3fceb5ae09f5d2fe85e97d361f684214bd91c27954a bitcoin-f015e1c2cac9-osx-unsigned.dmg
3c1e412bc7f5a7a5d0f78e2cd84b7096831414e1304c1307211aa3e135d89bbf bitcoin-f015e1c2cac9-osx-unsigned.tar.gz
50b7b2804e8481f63c69c78e3e8a71c0d811bf2db8895dd6d3edae9c46a738ae bitcoin-f015e1c2cac9-osx64.tar.gz
fe6b5c0a550096b76b6727efee30e85b60163a41c83f21868c849fdd9876b675 src/bitcoin-f015e1c2cac9.tar.gz
8a20f21b20673dfc8c23e22b20ae0839bcaf65bf0e02f62381cdf5e7922936f0 bitcoin-core-osx-22-res.yml
# Windows:
b01fcdc2a5673387050d6c6c4f96f1d350976a121155fde3f76c2af309111f9d bitcoin-f015e1c2cac9-win-unsigned.tar.gz
b95bdcbef638804030671d2332d58011f8c4ed4c1db87d6ffd211515c32c9d02 bitcoin-f015e1c2cac9-win64-debug.zip
350bf180252d24a3d40f05e22398fec7bb00e06d812204eb5a421100a8e10638 bitcoin-f015e1c2cac9-win64-setup-unsigned.exe
2730ddabe246d99913c9a779e97edcadb2d55309933d46f1dffd0d23ecf9aae5 bitcoin-f015e1c2cac9-win64.zip
fe6b5c0a550096b76b6727efee30e85b60163a41c83f21868c849fdd9876b675 src/bitcoin-f015e1c2cac9.tar.gz
aa60d7a753e8cb2d4323cfbbf4d964ad3645e74c918cccd66862888f8646d80f bitcoin-core-win-22-res.yml
```
ACKs for top commit:
hebasto:
ACK aa80b5759d, tested by breaking tests:
Tree-SHA512: 10150219910e8131715fbfe20edaa15778387616ef3bfe1a5152c7acd3958fe8f88c74961c3d3641074eb72824680c22764bb1dc01a19e92e946c2d4962a8d2c
e2c40a4ed5 guix-attest: Error out if SHA256SUMS is unexpected (Carl Dong)
4cc35daed5 Rewrite guix-{attest,verify} for new hier (Carl Dong)
28a9c9b839 Make SHA256SUMS fragment right after build (Carl Dong)
Pull request description:
Based on: #22075
Code reviewers: I recommend reading the new `guix-{attest,verify}` files instead of trying to read the diff
The following changes resolve many usability improvements which were pointed out to me:
1. Some maintainers like to extract their "uncodesigned tarball" inside the `output/` directory, resulting in the older `guix-attest` mistakenly attesting to the extracted contents
2. Maintainers whose GPG keys reside on an external smartcard often need to physically interact with the smartcard as a way to approve the signing operation, having one signature per platform means a lot of fidgeting
3. Maintainers wishing to sign on a separate machine now has the option of transferring only a subtree of `output/`, namely `output/*/SHA256SUMS.part`, in order to perform a signature (you may need to specify an `$OUTDIR_BASE` env var)
4. An `all.SHA256SUMS` file should be usable as the base `SHA256SUMS` in bitcoin core torrents and on the release server.
For those who sign on an separate machine than the one you do builds on, the following steps will work:
1. `env GUIX_SIGS_REPO=/home/achow101/guix.sigs SIGNER=achow101 NO_SIGN=1 ./contrib/guix/guix-attest`
2. Copy `/home/achow101/guix.sigs/<tag>/achow101` (which does not yet have signatures) to signing machine
3. Sign the `SHA256SUMS` files:
```bash
for i in "<path-to-achow101>/*.SHA256SUMS"; do
gpg --detach-sign --local-user "<your-key-here>" --armor --output "$i"{.asc,}
done
```
5. Upload `<path-to-achow101>` (now with signatures) to `guix.sigs`
-----
After this change, output directories will now include a `SHA256SUMS.part` fragment, created immediately after a successful build:
```
output
└── x86_64-w64-mingw32
├── bitcoin-4e069f7589da-win64-debug.zip
├── bitcoin-4e069f7589da-win64-setup-unsigned.exe
├── bitcoin-4e069f7589da-win64.zip
├── bitcoin-4e069f7589da-win-unsigned.tar.gz
└── SHA256SUMS.part
```
These `SHA256SUMS.part` fragments look something like:
```
3ebd7262b1a0a5bb757fef1f70e7e14033c70f98c059bc4dbfee5d1992b25825 dist-archive/bitcoin-4e069f7589da.tar.gz
def2e7d3de5ab3e3f955344e75151df4f33713f9101f5295bd13c9375bdf633b x86_64-w64-mingw32/bitcoin-4e069f7589da-win64-debug.zip
643049fe3ee4a4e83a1739607e67b11b7c9b1a66208a6f35a9ff634ba795500e x86_64-w64-mingw32/bitcoin-4e069f7589da-win64-setup-unsigned.exe
a247a1ccec0ccc2e138c648284bd01f6a761f2d8d6d07d91b5b4a6670ec3f288 x86_64-w64-mingw32/bitcoin-4e069f7589da-win-unsigned.tar.gz
fab76a836dcc592e39c04fd2396696633fb6eb56e39ecbf6c909bd173ed4280c x86_64-w64-mingw32/bitcoin-4e069f7589da-win64.zip
```
Meaning that they are valid `SHA256SUMS` files when `sha256sum --check`'d at the `guix-build-*/output` directory level
When `guix-attest` is invoked, these `SHA256SUMS.part` files are combined and sorted (by `-k2`, `LC_ALL=C`) to create:
1. `noncodesigned.SHA256SUMS` for a manifest of all non-codesigned outputs, and
3. `all.SHA256SUMS` for a manifest of all outputs including non-codesigned outputs
Then both files are signed, resulting in the following `guix.sigs` hierarchy:
```
4e069f7589da/
└── dongcarl
├── all.SHA256SUMS
├── all.SHA256SUMS.asc
├── noncodesigned.SHA256SUMS
└── noncodesigned.SHA256SUMS.asc
```
ACKs for top commit:
achow101:
ACK e2c40a4ed5
hebasto:
ACK e2c40a4ed5, tested on Linux Mint 20.1 (x86_64) with and w/o `NO_SIGN=1`. Changes in `contrib/guix/libexec/codesign.sh` and `contrib/guix/guix-verify` are reviewed only.
Tree-SHA512: 618aacefb0eb6595735a9ab6a98ea6598fce65f9ccf33fa1e7ef93bf140c0f6cfc16e34870c6aa3e4777dd3f004b92a82a994141879870141742df948ec59c1f
7fc5e865b9 test: install lief in CI (fanquake)
955140b326 contrib: consolidate PIE and NX security checks (fanquake)
2aa1631822 contrib: use LIEF in PE symbol checks (fanquake)
e93ac26b85 contrib: use LIEF in macOS symbol checks (fanquake)
a632cbcee5 contrib: use f strings in symbol-check.py (fanquake)
0f5d77c8e4 contrib: add PE PIE check to security checks (fanquake)
8e1f40dd9a contrib: use LIEF for PE security checks (fanquake)
a25b2e965c contrib: use LIEF for macOS security checks (fanquake)
7e7eae7aa8 contrib: use f strings in security-check.py (fanquake)
2e7a9f7ade guix: install LIEF in Guix container (fanquake)
465967b5ef gitian: install LIEF in gitian container (fanquake)
Pull request description:
This PR is a proof of concept for using [LIEF](https://github.com/lief-project/LIEF) for the PE and MACHO symbol and security checks. It replaces our current approach of manually parsing the output of `objdump` & `otool`. If the consensus is that using LIEF is ok, then I also plan on replacing [pixie.py](https://github.com/bitcoin/bitcoin/blob/master/contrib/devtools/pixie.py), and using LIEF for all checks. LIEF for Linux is also currently blocked (on the next release, unless we want to build master) on one change for RISC-V that I [sent upstream](https://github.com/lief-project/LIEF/pull/562).
LIEF is seemingly well maintained, and is the basis for a number of other tools. It also has some very nice documentation; i.e the [Python API for ELF](https://lief.quarkslab.com/doc/latest/api/python/elf.html). It also has many builtins we can take advantage of. i.e [`is_pie`](https://lief.quarkslab.com/doc/latest/api/python/macho.html#lief.MachO.Binary.is_pie), [`has_nx`](https://lief.quarkslab.com/doc/latest/api/python/macho.html#lief.MachO.Binary.has_nx) etc. This means we can [consolidate some of our checks](9c5eeb5484). If/when end up using LIEF for lightning then we can consolidate further, and cleanup these scripts. i.e to not parse the binary inside the checks, but once at the start of the script.
Guix builds:
```bash
# find guix-build-$(git rev-parse --short=12 HEAD)/output/ -type f -print0 | env LC_ALL=C sort -z | xargs -r0 sha256sum
963a08638c46f9a3d75cd4b0c155d1ca091bbeba27167291adcd3dca03fd4c3d guix-build-f51237d94d98/output/aarch64-linux-gnu/bitcoin-f51237d94d98-aarch64-linux-gnu-debug.tar.gz
a3ce927c46b103789a010c41a6ebfafe4548d90ee7d88f2a735c9183b775da5c guix-build-f51237d94d98/output/aarch64-linux-gnu/bitcoin-f51237d94d98-aarch64-linux-gnu.tar.gz
2503ac8901068805d5e7251fd5cfeb7c1f8ba3528bdfcf3aa1e0c40bfd5c1cbc guix-build-f51237d94d98/output/arm-linux-gnueabihf/bitcoin-f51237d94d98-arm-linux-gnueabihf-debug.tar.gz
5798697e58e1788df85aa9e2e4d33fef0456169fcbd2521f13b3b5806ac0d84d guix-build-f51237d94d98/output/arm-linux-gnueabihf/bitcoin-f51237d94d98-arm-linux-gnueabihf.tar.gz
4185adebc6a0abe7241a3cd409a6ab7be031c26f1c4245e30bb5f87eef0925d2 guix-build-f51237d94d98/output/dist-archive/bitcoin-f51237d94d98.tar.gz
9b4b8756c5c84295eb6b61b6b32a07a8d07723fb38aaa8f519b6133935061bda guix-build-f51237d94d98/output/powerpc64-linux-gnu/bitcoin-f51237d94d98-powerpc64-linux-gnu-debug.tar.gz
cbd821aa464a9c16f7979dbec1a5e66939e777a567f55f7081499a8d528d42c5 guix-build-f51237d94d98/output/powerpc64-linux-gnu/bitcoin-f51237d94d98-powerpc64-linux-gnu.tar.gz
abed530a82e97e3cf621c90a13c0881b0e39ccce2a6f42a3ff80de76e2abc5f7 guix-build-f51237d94d98/output/powerpc64le-linux-gnu/bitcoin-f51237d94d98-powerpc64le-linux-gnu-debug.tar.gz
8b6d2bdd8b58ff1f6072bf8693abe3ce773ff3a7d8d2b7218207e69945b9d31b guix-build-f51237d94d98/output/powerpc64le-linux-gnu/bitcoin-f51237d94d98-powerpc64le-linux-gnu.tar.gz
d99cc705032d22ae819975992216899ed960ba25871a05c8789d00b80418511f guix-build-f51237d94d98/output/riscv64-linux-gnu/bitcoin-f51237d94d98-riscv64-linux-gnu-debug.tar.gz
5240ca4f4ef7c62088185224ac319ad9a4a9b40075df10af18d8a6355bca32fb guix-build-f51237d94d98/output/riscv64-linux-gnu/bitcoin-f51237d94d98-riscv64-linux-gnu.tar.gz
adc16eaee4b51e8615ce8b3be9f6c018698237df4ad6e0886cf0d4ab6bc9e5c4 guix-build-f51237d94d98/output/x86_64-apple-darwin18/bitcoin-f51237d94d98-osx-unsigned.dmg
b188af0572ee682d74cc82c7e6e464115205fc130a457cfe19d42ac9ddd267f8 guix-build-f51237d94d98/output/x86_64-apple-darwin18/bitcoin-f51237d94d98-osx-unsigned.tar.gz
e764062fde144e6fb5d6dd776c10fc2daa8d775831f7e43247d17a6c6e060c97 guix-build-f51237d94d98/output/x86_64-apple-darwin18/bitcoin-f51237d94d98-osx64.tar.gz
dab3d26ac94c669140f7329d14e57ef02b0fe92b8a8f9d96c32a416adea0da0f guix-build-f51237d94d98/output/x86_64-linux-gnu/bitcoin-f51237d94d98-x86_64-linux-gnu-debug.tar.gz
ca59d4379fbe2b9a52deebeaf88508e0eda4215f28d319aff0781289dd159712 guix-build-f51237d94d98/output/x86_64-linux-gnu/bitcoin-f51237d94d98-x86_64-linux-gnu.tar.gz
52b7c35321a85c4f6c95bf0e687574454b71ede9bec1c9cf17f37c578c888a94 guix-build-f51237d94d98/output/x86_64-w64-mingw32/bitcoin-f51237d94d98-win-unsigned.tar.gz
a543895a00f8ffb3ba50ca68396d52ad5a18dd8efe38730e0049dd70d283a092 guix-build-f51237d94d98/output/x86_64-w64-mingw32/bitcoin-f51237d94d98-win64-debug.zip
aec050d03c65268a986148500f7341cceb8c5f85287e0e3cde8933ce4b4dee32 guix-build-f51237d94d98/output/x86_64-w64-mingw32/bitcoin-f51237d94d98-win64-setup-unsigned.exe
57ba33ed6ee8d3a885e342471359301473e83037d5442895beb686921a4c50e9 guix-build-f51237d94d98/output/x86_64-w64-mingw32/bitcoin-f51237d94d98-win64.zip
```
Gitian builds:
```bash
# macOS:
2f066e852bdd30ac46e5ecdf7619d19d408035c318a3edf0f1893ec2e25efb69 bitcoin-41a1b3d1b130-osx-unsigned.dmg
8cf8ac4d21740f490262453c330b5f4a5c5b8139dfc1b322efefce3f3b93d1b2 bitcoin-41a1b3d1b130-osx-unsigned.tar.gz
cf1b84efdd9d2588a1ce9513580fb56b38bfafe60e18f8adbeedf03521c6c2b2 bitcoin-41a1b3d1b130-osx64.tar.gz
14995244b0bb3e80e7b79975c9c70fdfb3ee3c04fda3efd5358ce1c4efa3a312 src/bitcoin-41a1b3d1b130.tar.gz
93881069d5e1dc385c08895a7b035a94eb010325afc2776c99b6aafa21096eb8 bitcoin-core-osx-22-res.yml
# Windows:
4d56dd7713121684b7eaa448679c65df2fd0aa5319bf8d12fb6cfa9f0b005cf7 bitcoin-f51237d94d98-win-unsigned.tar.gz
4558f4173152b084bcba25aa1a53c605208a70fe20392141b63cefb476528c85 bitcoin-f51237d94d98-win64-debug.zip
b63feaca010e86d514cfe38d716e3c8a8b8058e4f969b868aaaeb8a8a3d3dc81 bitcoin-f51237d94d98-win64-setup-unsigned.exe
de7d8586cc91ba391fe911853a99d9fd15fc6f9a60f9b91a0447940173aac67a bitcoin-f51237d94d98-win64.zip
4185adebc6a0abe7241a3cd409a6ab7be031c26f1c4245e30bb5f87eef0925d2 src/bitcoin-f51237d94d98.tar.gz
45efaca35b5fad0a04dfd06e44f7c00b990aa91c7bf2faea57e020d3491a6cf0 bitcoin-core-win-22-res.yml
# Linux:
055d646c5f8cf4708008374546176012ff758566a2645a3a01e1a33eab1002fe bitcoin-f51237d94d98-aarch64-linux-gnu-debug.tar.gz
bfc8b0efc36b0474c88546b12d2723c04b4dc629ae311082025c7e0b8f0d1aa9 bitcoin-f51237d94d98-aarch64-linux-gnu.tar.gz
9dfaa5acfffadad8942b32996458013a155d12ed07be76601f232233627b5cb9 bitcoin-f51237d94d98-arm-linux-gnueabihf-debug.tar.gz
54eb57905ff8513b9f628707b61aa4659c362fb2f6d17e0ee240b4da3674907d bitcoin-f51237d94d98-arm-linux-gnueabihf.tar.gz
ad98d876616eff578ad8cfd17dfbabe48ed14200823579687d66694bae3d2fe3 bitcoin-f51237d94d98-powerpc64-linux-gnu-debug.tar.gz
fe1b421dd1cb6e04d5dc5d341459dc15fa6e15b80906e5d8e0405cf43495e0f7 bitcoin-f51237d94d98-powerpc64-linux-gnu.tar.gz
9001d95cc7d2722d9d7dd83d9da8e5adf575fddf91b615b76b9bcfece30ecf6f bitcoin-f51237d94d98-powerpc64le-linux-gnu-debug.tar.gz
9e0650ad2aba70c0fd1608a077e95f335dc1bb4a79eab9b0b56ac87427a4fd4f bitcoin-f51237d94d98-powerpc64le-linux-gnu.tar.gz
fbfde0134944d3dbd32991455b0a8abdd334853ab8a4c1a1a4c060d9de071c50 bitcoin-f51237d94d98-riscv64-linux-gnu-debug.tar.gz
2fa2cfddce98c44c65305326fc623a7f065129208337503d813a08d51580cb8a bitcoin-f51237d94d98-riscv64-linux-gnu.tar.gz
b2d6caeee0e3c350a43165c39876ebed8e588958007af0d06996e341c7060683 bitcoin-f51237d94d98-x86_64-linux-gnu-debug.tar.gz
bfdb827e75d43d61462513c9a843620b93c9160d9d246cad13278baaa07f64ea bitcoin-f51237d94d98-x86_64-linux-gnu.tar.gz
4185adebc6a0abe7241a3cd409a6ab7be031c26f1c4245e30bb5f87eef0925d2 src/bitcoin-f51237d94d98.tar.gz
34820a093916fa35b0fd98806a50092f46b20271af7422f43e2a4223ef6f9bb7 bitcoin-core-linux-22-res.yml
```
ACKs for top commit:
laanwj:
re-ACK 7fc5e865b9
Tree-SHA512: 0c30838413448ecfcf55e6273f607fdb01cb1acafa1d2762afad59360fca7d8efa78ec55064f50cba56cb2c9e98741e13665cba8e9b4b8e5b62b8a53f9bf8990
This relatively easy change eliminates all runtime dependencies (except
for the kernel) for dmg, which is the only native build tool that gets
put in our output tarballs.
This allows much more flexibility when constructing the codesigning
environment, and is much more robust.
Bump glibc and linux-headers to match those of our Gitian counterparts.
We also require a glibc >= 2.28 for the test-symbol-check scripts to
work properly.
The default BASE-GCC-FOR-LIBC also has to be bumped since glibc 2.31
requires a gcc >= 6.2
The new time-machine commit is Guix v1.2.0 with a yet-unupstreamed patch
for NSIS.
A few important changes:
1. Guix switched back from using CPATH to C{,PLUS}_INCLUDE_PATH as the
way to indicate #include search paths.
2. GCC's library is now split into a separate output, whereas before it
was included in the default output. This means that our gcc toolchain
packages need to propagate that output.
3. A few package versions were bumped
When building nsis, if VERSION is not specified, it defaults to
cvs_version which is non-deterministic as it includes the current date.
This patches nsis to default to SOURCE_DATE_EPOCH if it exists so that
nsis is reproducible.
Upstream change: https://github.com/kichik/nsis/pull/13
The libtool unsorted 'find' determinism issue seemed to have been solved
in gcc-9's git: d41cd173e23ebea7c758644d6ad6e0fde1c2e3a6 or SVN: r262451
Furthermore, it seems that Ubuntu Focal 20.04 LTS is going to ship with
gcc 9 and mingw-w64 7, which will match what we have now.
-----
A note on this:
Careful observers will see that previously I stated that all released
versions of gcc were bootstrapped with a libtool 2.2.7a, meaning that
they all had the unsorted 'find' determinism issue first resolved in
libtool 2.2.7b.
However, I was mistaken, gcc's ltmain.sh CLAIMS it was generated by
libtool 2.2.7a, but it was in fact edited manually. It seems that gcc
maintains their own versions of ltmain.sh and libtool.m4, and only
sometimes backports patches from upstream.
Quite confusing.
Previously, Guix would produce a gcc which did not know to use the SSP
function from glibc, and required a gcc make flag for it to do so, in my
attempt to fix it upstream I realized that this is no longer the case.
This can be verified by performing a Guix build and doing
readelf -s ... | grep __stack_chk
to check that symbols are coming from glibc, and doing
readelf -d ... | grep NEEDED | grep ssp
to see that libssp.so is not being depended on
- Clearer and more accurate prose
- Pin `guix pull' to commit rather than branch
- Just use `use-module' instead of `define-module'
- Use `bash-minimal' instead of `bash'
- Remove unneeded `tcsh' from manifest
- Explicitly use `python-3.7'
- Add comments about how {native,cross}-toolchains are produced and
why
Carl Dong